I didn't say anything about eloping. [Which, logic says, means you were thinking about it already.

He will purse his lips and cross his own arms, effectively staring Rachel down from her bed. Which... he's taken over. For now.]

Just a song? The Birthday Song is just a song. Les Mis is something else entirely. Especially if he actually managed to get off his high horse and sing it and not sound like a sad excuse for a synthesizer.

Which, from how you're acting about it, I assume he did.