[...No indeed Rachel you put him in quite a spot - he'll look at her. And no, he won't lie to her. He did it once and it was bad enough]

You know Rachel - when I did what I did to you, I told you that, I told you I loved you, and it was a lie. I couldn't tell you that I love you. I didn't thought you loved me back at all. I thought it was Finn all along. But I can't lie to you now. I can't tell you 'I loved you too'. I know you wanted a closure - but I won't lie to you again about this."