[He feels so bad about this whole thing - but she's right, he shouldn't have left, they should have probably had this conversation a year ago]

I didn't think it mattered to you - I didn't know you loved me. I thought you loved Finn, and that I'm clearing the way for you to be together and - lead New Directions. And then at Regionals, you sang Faithfully and I was sure I had it right. That you loved Finn, and not me.

[Finn and Rachel - Rachel and Finn - singing 'I'm forever yours Faithfully' Jesse in return singing 'Nothing really matters to me' - how fitting. But Rachel loved him, back then she did and suddenly this whole situation was so frustrating. If only they talked, then]